Disputes with state authorities

First consultation free of charge (Mon–Fri, 9:00–18:00)

Call +380 (97) 158-30-28

In a dispute with a public authority the law takes the individual’s side on the central point: it is for the authority to prove that its decision was lawful. The lawyer’s task is to choose the right remedy and not to miss the filing deadline.

When to get in touch

  • an authority has taken a decision that infringes your rights
  • a service or a document has been refused without proper grounds
  • the authority is failing to take action it is obliged to take
  • the authority needs to be ordered to take a specific decision
  • the authority has not dealt with an application or complaint within the time limit

Recognise your situation?

First consultation free of charge (Mon–Fri, 9:00–18:00). The fee for further work is agreed in writing before it begins – how we calculate fees.

Call +380 (97) 158-30-28

What the lawyer does

  • analyses the authority’s decision and identifies the appropriate remedy
  • prepares pre-action applications and complaints
  • prepares the administrative claim within the filing deadline
  • assembles the evidence and requires the authority to justify its decision
  • represents the client before the courts at every level
  • sees the authority’s compliance with the judgment through
  • applies for suspension of the challenged act and for interim measures
  • asks the court to order the authority to report on compliance with the judgment

Complaint to a higher-level authority

  • An administrative act, as well as a procedural decision, action or omission of an authority, may be challenged administratively if it infringes or may infringe a person’s rights, freedoms or legitimate interests (part 1 of Article 78 of the Law of Ukraine “On Administrative Procedure”, hereinafter – the Administrative Procedure Law).
  • The complaint is considered by the higher-level authority, unless the law designates another body. It is lodged through the authority that issued the act, which must forward it with the case file no later than the next day (part 1 of Article 79 and part 1 of Article 82 of the Administrative Procedure Law).
  • A complaint against an act is lodged within 30 calendar days of the day the person was notified of the act. A complaint against an omission may be lodged at any time after the time limit for adopting the act has expired. If the act does not state the time limit and procedure for challenging it, the time limit is not considered missed (parts 1 and 4 of Article 80 of the Administrative Procedure Law).
  • At the complainant’s request, lodging the complaint suspends the challenged act, except in cases provided for by law (part 4 of Article 83 of the Administrative Procedure Law).
  • A complaint is reviewed within no more than 30 calendar days; this period may be extended once by no more than 15 calendar days (parts 3 and 4 of Article 34 of the Administrative Procedure Law).
  • A written act must contain a statement of reasons, including the facts of the case, references to the evidence and a detailed legal assessment (parts 1 and 2 of Article 72 of the Administrative Procedure Law). An act lacking a mandatory statement of reasons is quashed on complaint (part 3 of Article 85 of the Administrative Procedure Law).
  • The Administrative Procedure Law does not apply, in particular, to relations in the civil service and other public service, the application of legislation on national security and defence and on citizenship, or to enforcement proceedings (except for the enforcement of administrative acts) (part 2 of Article 1 of the Administrative Procedure Law).

Complaint or straight to court: filing deadlines

  • The general time limit for applying to the administrative court is six months from the day the person learned or should have learned of the infringement of their rights (part 2 of Article 122 of the Code of Administrative Proceedings of Ukraine, CAP).
  • If the person has used the pre-trial procedure, or that procedure is mandatory, the time limit for going to court is three months from the day the decision on the complaint was served. If the decision on the complaint was not adopted or not served within the statutory time limit, it is six months from the day the complaint was lodged (part 4 of Article 122 of the CAP).
  • In disputes about admission to public service, its performance and dismissal from it, the time limit for going to court is one month (part 5 of Article 122 of the CAP).
  • Filing a claim does not in itself suspend the challenged decision; for that the court must order interim measures – in particular, suspending the act or prohibiting the defendant from taking certain actions. One of the grounds is obvious signs that the decision is unlawful and infringes the person’s rights (parts 2 and 4 of Article 150 and part 1 of Article 151 of the CAP).

What the court examines

In cases challenging decisions, actions or omissions of public authorities, the court examines whether the decision was taken (the action was performed):

  • on the basis, within the powers and in the manner provided for by the Constitution and the laws of Ukraine;
  • for the purpose for which the power was conferred;
  • with good reason, that is, taking into account all relevant circumstances;
  • impartially, in good faith and reasonably;
  • with respect for equality before the law and without discrimination;
  • proportionately – keeping a balance between the adverse consequences for the person and the aim of the decision;
  • taking into account the person’s right to take part in the decision-making process;
  • in good time, that is, within a reasonable time (part 2 of Article 2 of the CAP).

The authority must submit to the court all the documents and materials in its possession that may be used as evidence in the case (part 2 of Article 77 of the CAP).

Ordering a decision and compensation for damage

  • If all the conditions laid down by law for taking the decision have been met and the authority has no right to act at its own discretion, the court may order it to take a decision in the claimant’s favour (part 4 of Article 245 of the CAP).
  • If, however, the decision involves the authority’s right to act at its own discretion, the court orders the authority to decide the matter taking into account the legal assessment given in the judgment (part 4 of Article 245 of the CAP).
  • Together with a declaration that a decision, action or omission is unlawful, the claimant may seek recovery from the authority of compensation for the damage caused by it (point 6 of part 1 of Article 5 of the CAP).

Enforcement of the judgment

  • A judgment that has become final is binding on all authorities and officials; failure to comply with it entails liability established by law (Article 370 of the CAP).
  • On the application of the person in whose favour the judgment was given, the court may order the authority to submit a report on compliance with it. The application may be made while the case is still being heard – before the end of the closing arguments or, under the simplified procedure, within 30 days of the opening of proceedings (parts 1 and 5 of Article 382 of the CAP).
  • The time limit for the report is at least 10 calendar days from the day the authority receives the court’s ruling and no more than three months; the court may require the head of the authority to report in person (parts 3 and 4 of Article 382-1 of the CAP).
  • If the court does not accept the report, it fines the head of the authority between 20 and 40 times the subsistence minimum for able-bodied persons; half of the fine is paid to the applicant. A fine is also imposed where the report is not submitted on time without good reason (parts 3, 4 and 10 of Article 382-3 of the CAP).

Specific types of dispute are covered on the pages “Land disputes with public authorities”, “Licences and permits”, “Immigration matters and citizenship”, “Challenging actions of the enforcement service” and “Challenging administrative rulings and fines”.

Legal basis

The jurisdiction of the administrative courts is set out in Article 19 of the Code of Administrative Proceedings of Ukraine; the available remedies, including a declaration that a decision is unlawful and an order to take action, in Article 5. In cases about the unlawfulness of decisions, acts or omissions, the burden of proving lawfulness rests on the public authority (part two of Article 77). The general filing deadline is six months (Article 122). Administrative (pre-trial) challenges are governed by Articles 78–85 of the Law of Ukraine “On Administrative Procedure”, and the time limit for reviewing a complaint by Article 34 of that Law. The criteria by which the court examines decisions of authorities are set out in part 2 of Article 2 of the CAP, the time limit for going to court after a complaint in part 4 of Article 122, interim measures in Articles 150 and 151, the powers of the court in Article 245, and the binding force of judgments and judicial control over their enforcement in Articles 370 and 382–382-3 of the CAP.

Legislation and case law are updated over time; this page reflects the position as of November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Who has to prove the authority’s decision was lawful?

The authority itself: in cases about the unlawfulness of its decisions the burden of proof rests on the public authority (part 2 of Article 77 of the Code of Administrative Proceedings).

Can an authority be ordered to take a particular decision?

The Code provides for that remedy (Article 5); whether it is available depends on whether the matter is discretionary. If all the conditions laid down by law have been met and the authority has no right to act at its own discretion, the court orders it to take a decision in the claimant’s favour; if it does have that right, the court orders it to decide the matter taking into account the court’s legal assessment (part 4 of Article 245 of the Code of Administrative Proceedings).

Do I have to complain to a higher-level authority first?

No, unless the law makes the pre-trial procedure mandatory: otherwise a complaint is an option, not a condition for going to court. But if a complaint has been lodged, the time limit for going to court is three months from the day the decision on the complaint was served, and if that decision was not adopted or not served on time – six months from the day the complaint was lodged (part 4 of Article 122 of the Code of Administrative Proceedings).

Need legal assistance? Call us or leave a request – a lawyer will contact you and explain what to do in your situation.

How we work

  1. You submit a request

  2. We analyse your situation

  3. We agree a strategy with you

  4. We protect your interests

Similar services

  1. Challenging administrative rulings and fines
  2. Immigration matters and citizenship
  3. Licences and permits
  • 2020

    year founded

  • 9

    attorneys on the team

  • 11

    practice areas

  • 24/7

    urgent legal assistance

Have a similar situation? First consultation free of charge (Mon–Fri, 9:00–18:00).

Call